There's a specific moment I look for before I ever get on a call with a prospective client: the point where what they're asking for and what they may truly need come into focus, sometimes before we've even spoken.
Earlier this year, I was referred to a specialty school for a fractional CMO opening. Before the intro call, I spent time looking at what I thought prospective students would most likely see while they were deciding next steps. What I found was a listing quietly pointing to an old identity and outdated links. A LinkedIn page with real followers and no activity. Reviews that were thin for a business with twenty-plus years of credibility. I tagged these as immediate fixes before our call, because I consider them a strong signal, not of a broken business, but of an unattended one.
Being useful and being hired are not the same thing. What happened next tested this directly.
The initial conversation surfaced a real, urgent challenge with an exact deadline attached. They needed to fill seats. They were paying an agency thousands of dollars a month for content, social, and paid ads, historically a successful spend for them. But enrollment for the upcoming program was sitting at roughly a quarter of its usual capacity with less than two months to fill it. SEO wasn't performing the way it normally did, the economy wasn't helping, and no one had a clear read on why enrollment had fallen. A second meeting was scheduled with the leadership team in the room, and I was asked to come with solutions and a strategy.
What mattered to me in that room wasn't tactics. It was the weight of the decision a prospective student must make, including both time and money. Choosing a specialty program is not an impulse purchase. It's considered, often with a little anxiety, deeply personal, and has a real cost if it's the wrong decision.
No one in the room could tell me what moves someone from considering the program to enrolling. Not the timeline. Not the trigger. Not the hesitation that keeps a prospect from committing. There was no system in place to reveal that data.
I also have to be honest about what I didn't ask and why the miss mattered. The discovery call was thirty minutes, compressed by circumstance, and I moved through it without asking the one question that would have changed everything: how long does a student typically take from first awareness to enrollment? Without that, I couldn't know whether eight weeks was a realistic window, or whether the prospects we needed were already inside a decision cycle that simply needed better follow-through to capture them. A thirty-minute call is not an excuse: it's a flag. One I now know to raise before any enrollment-based discovery conversation ever begins. That question is a standing part of my framework because of this engagement.
A best guess dressed up as a plan is exactly the kind of thinking that can get a business into this position and gives marketing a bad rap.
Maybe the easier play would've been to promise the full class by the deadline and hand over a handful of rapid-fire tactics. It would have made for a smoother meeting. But I didn't do that, because I simply didn't know enough at that time to make that promise responsibly, or even confidently.
So I presented a few recommendations in a follow-up and put immediate, actionable tasks in front of them that had nothing to do with hiring me.
Build a copy framework: a single document naming who their student is, what they're afraid of, what they're hoping for, and why they'd choose this program over every other option. It allows the agency to align messaging and create a unified urgency across all platforms.
Review and correct the listings pointing to a retired identity. A credibility leak that costs trust before a prospective student ever reaches the website. An easy five-minute fix.
Engage the alumni community. Only a small fraction had left a review or actively been asked for referrals. An easily accessible and untapped social proof leverage point that no ad budget can buy.
One more thing surfaced that changed the frame entirely: a casual mention of a horizon to sell, with no specific timeline named. If that was in fact real, the work in front of them wasn't only about filling a single class. It was about building the systems, the data, and the brand clarity that makes a business easy for someone else to understand and buy. A buyer doesn't purchase an enrollment number; they purchase a business they can replicate.
What I could promise, and did, was that the work done inside that window would compound. Every class after that one would benefit from it, whether I was the one doing the work or not. That felt like a more honest offer than a filled class I simply could not guarantee.
I wasn't awarded the engagement, and we went our separate ways. Sometimes being on target about the diagnosis isn't the same thing as being able to deliver success on someone else's calendar.
Filling one class fast and building a school truly positioned to sell someday are two different opportunities. I moved as fast as the foundation would allow me, and I wasn't going to pretend it could move faster.
I've since presented this scenario to a couple of trusted peers, they are also fractional CMOs, and asked what they would have done differently. Their answer was a version of the same approach. That helped, but it didn't close the loop for me.
If you had been in that room, what would you have asked that I didn't, especially in that first conversation?
Jessica Martin, CFE is a Fractional CMO who helps small and midsize businesses move from chaos to clarity through alignment. I work with franchise organizations and growing SMB companies to build the marketing foundations that make sustainable growth possible.
Ready to talk hourly strategic consulting?
See how the hourly strategic consulting engagement works.
